|
Unit
7. Using
Technology to Teach Reading Skills
|
Please read
Butler-Pascoe, M. E. & Wiburg, K. M. (2003).
Technology and teaching English language learners.
Chapter 5, pp. 114-137. |
7.1 The Role of Reading in SLA
7.1.1 Three Models of Reading
Process
7.1.2 Reading and Schema Theory
7.2 Teaching
Reading
Skills and the Use of Computers
7.2.1 Automatic Word Recognition
Skills
7.2.2 Vocabulary and Structural
Knowledge
7.2.3 Formal Discourse Structure
Knowledge
7.2.4 Content / World Background
Knowledge
7.2.5 Synthesis and Evaluation
Skills
7.2.6 Metacognitive
Knowledge and Skills
7.1 The Role of Reading in SLA
7.1.1 Three Models of Reading
Process
The reading process involves the text, the reader, and
the interaction between the two. Theorists have proposed
three basic models of how reading occurs: bottom-up,
top-down, and interactive.
|
Bottom-Up Models |
Top-Down Models |
Interactive Models |
|
1960s - 1970s |
1970s - 1980s |
late 1980s - present
|
|
- Reading is a decoding process (focus on the
text).
- The phonics approach to teaching reading is
used. |
- Reading is a psycholinguistic guessing game
(focus on the reader).
- The "whole language" approach to teaching
reading is used. |
- Reading is a process of constructing meaning from
text through the use of both bottom-up and
top-down processes, strategies, and skills (focus on
the interaction).
- The balanced approach to teaching reading is
used. |
|
1) alphabet letters + sounds
g words
2) words + grammar rules
g sentences
3)
sentences + discourse rules g paragraphs
g
longer discourse
|
1) The reader receives input from the text,
makes predictions (based on conceptual abilities, background
knowledge, and language processing skills), tests and
confirms or revises those prediction.
2) Use a holistic approach to reading and writing that
advocates the use of children's literature and authentic
reading materials. |
1) Both bottom-up and top-down processes occur
simultaneously for the reader to comprehend the
meaning of the text.
2) Two levels of interaction:
- the interaction between the reader and the
text.
- the interaction between two kinds of cognitive skills:
identification and interpretation. |
7.1.2 Reading and Schema Theory
The function of background knowledge in the reading process
is formalized in schema theory. According to schema
theory, the reader brings previously acquired background knowledge
organized into interrelated patterns, or schemata, to the reading
process. Then the reader creates meaning by relating the text to
this background knowledge, including knowledge of customs and
beliefs from his or her own experiences.
Three are three types of schemata that have an impact on reading
comprehension:
-
Formal schemata: prior knowledge of rhetorical structures
and conventions (e.g. different types of expository
organizational patterns: cause and effect, comparison and
contrast, problem and solution, and chronological order, etc.)
-
Content schemata: background knowledge of the subject of
the text, which is often culture-bound.
-
Linguistic schemata: decoding knowledge used to recognize
words and determine their syntax in a sentence; that is, prior
knowledge of a particular vocabulary and grammar rules.
* Discussion Questions:
-
Please examine your reading process and find out what approach
you usually use in reading English. Do you use the same or
different approaches when reading texts in Chinese and in
English (or other foreign languages)?
-
Recall your reading experience in English that caused you
difficulty in comprehending a particular text. Then discuss
which schemata you think plays the most important role.
7.2 Teaching Reading Skills
and the Use of Computers
Grabe (1991) identified six component skills and knowledge
areas essential for reading fluency:
-
automatic word recognition skills
-
vocabulary and structure knowledge
-
formal discourse structure knowledge
-
content/world background knowledge
-
synthesis and evaluation skills
-
metacognitive knowledge and skills
7.2.1 Automatic Word
Recognition Skills
-
Automatic recognition skills allow readers to identify
letters and words without being consciously aware of the process.
Good readers are able to read rapidly because they can recognize
most words automatically, and therefore process this information
very efficiently. The combination of rapid and precise word
recognition has proven to be an effective predictor of
reading ability, particularly of young readers.
-
The use of computers to facilitate the development of
recognition skills
Examples of using the phonics approach:
- Learn to
Read at Starfall
-
BBC Words and Pictures
Examples for Speed Reading:
-
AceReader (download the AceReader Original Demo)
- Best
Reader (download the trial version)
7.2.2 Vocabulary and Structural
Knowledge
-
The importance of vocabulary learning for reading comprehension:
-
Readers need to know a large percentage (approximately 95%) of
the words in any given text in order to comprehend the meaning
of the reading or to guess the meaning of words unfamiliar to
them.
-
Vocabulary is not acquired in quick doses, but rather is a
process of incremental learning and constant reinforcement.
Readers need to know not just one meaning of a word in a
particular context but also its alternative meanings in
different contexts and other aspects of the word such as its
grammatical properties.
-
Things needed to be included in vocabulary lessons (Zimmerman,
1997):
-
multiple exposure to words
-
exposure to words in meaningful contexts
-
rich and varied information about each word
-
establishment of ties between instructed words student
experience, and prior knowledge
-
active participation by students in the learning process
-
The use of computers to facilitate vocabulary development:
Examples:
- Online dictionaries (see
3.2.2 Online
Dictionaries)
- Online concordancers (see
3.2.3 Online
Concordancers)
- Word games:
Word Based
Games for ESL Students
Vocabulary
for K-12 and ESL Kids
ESL games in
EnglishClub.com
-
The importance of grammar learning for reading comprehension:
Grammatical structures provide readers significant information
that allows them to understand the meaning relationships among
words and among sentences in a reading text.
-
The use of computers to facilitate the development of structural
skills:
Grammar Website Examples:
-
English Grammar from EnglishClub.com
-
Grammar from eflnet.com
-
Guide
to Grammar and Writing
-
Guide to Grammar and Style
7.2.3 Formal Discourse
Structure Knowledge
-
Knowledge of the structure of formal discourse / rhetorical
organizational patterns (i.e. formal schemata)
assists the learner in understanding and remembering the text.
Research indicated that explicit teaching of rhetorical
organization of text facilitated ESL students' reading
comprehension.
-
The use of computers to facilitate the development of discourse
structure knowledge:
Examples:
-
Advice on Academic Writing (from the University of Toronto)
-
Professional Writing Handouts and Resources (from Purdue
University)
7.2.4 Content / World
Background Knowledge
-
Activating the reader's knowledge of the subject matter
and cultural content of the text is a significant factor
in both reading comprehension and recall. Research shows
that L2 learners can better recall information from text on
topics familiar to them than readings of equivalent
difficulty level on subjects with which they are less familiar.
Moreover, readers can more easily comprehend and recall texts of
which the content is based on their own culture than
texts based on unfamiliar and more remote cultures.
-
The use of computers to facilitate the development of
content/world knowledge:
Examples:
-
BBC Learning English
- BBC
Schools (for ages 4-11, ages 11-16, and ages 16+)
-
CNN International
and
CNN Student News
-
Public
Broadcasting Service (PBS) and
PBS Kids
-
Discovery.com
and Discovery
Kids.com
-
New York Times Learning Network
7.2.5 Synthesis and
Evaluation Skills
-
Fluent readers are able not only to comprehend the text,
but to make judgments about the information,
the author's
purpose, and the usefulness of the text. They usually use
strategies like predicting to assist them in anticipating
text development and evaluating the author's perspective as they
read.
-
The use of computers to encourage students learning to
synthesize and evaluate reading text:
Examples:
-
Ace Detectives (mystery-solving game)
-
Story Mapping Activity
-
Dr. Alice Christie's Matrix of 282 WebQuests
7.2.6 Metacognitive
Knowledge and Skills
-
Metacognitive knowledge is knowledge about how learners think
and self-regulate their cognitive processes. It includes
knowledge about language and ability to recognize
structural and rhetorical features of the text using
suitable strategies for accomplishing particular goals.
-
In the reading process, metacognitive skills include recognizing main ideas, adjusting reading rate for
skimming, scanning, paraphrasing, and
summarizing, guessing meaning from word formation
rules, prefixes, and suffixes, and taking notes. The
ability to effectively apply metacognitive strategies to the
reading process is a key ingredient to skilled reading,
especially for older readers.
-
The use of computers to assist students in developing
metacognitive skills:
Examples:
-
Reading Strategies: Scaffolding Students' Interactions with Texts
-
Strategies for Reading Comprehension (from ReadingQuest.org)
-
Reading and Mapping Strategies
-
Effective Reading Strategies
* Discussion Question:
-
Among the six component skills and knowledge areas identified by
Grabe (1991), which one or ones do you think you need the most
to help you become an efficient reader in English? Explain your reasons and discuss
how the computer can provide help to your reading development of
that particular skill or knowledge area.
* Please do
Exercise 7 Using Technology to Teach Reading Skills
* Good reading
material collection websites:
-
The Online Books Page (University of Pennsylvania)
-
English Reading from E.L. Easton
-
English reading from EnlgishClub.com
-
Repeat after Us - Online Library and Language Lab
 |