|
|
Unit
5. Using
Technology to Teach Listening Skills
|
Please read
Butler-Pascoe, M. E. & Wiburg, K. M. (2003).
Technology and teaching English language learners.
Chapter 4, pp. 81-96. |
5.1 The Role of Listening in SLA
- The Comprehension Approach
- Krashen's Monitor Model
5.2 Approaches to the Teaching
of Listening
Skills
5.2.1 The Natural Approach
5.2.2 The Total Physical Response (TPR)
5.3 Listening Processes
5.4 Listening Purposes
5.1 The Role of Listening in SLA (second
language acquisition)
-
Listening was first recognized as a major component of language
learning and teaching in the late 1970s. At that time, research
suggested that language instruction should focus on the
learner's listening comprehension in the early stages of
acquisition, while delaying oral production until the learner
was more familiar with the new language.
-
This school of thought manifested itself in the form of the comprehension
approach which proposed the following:
-
Comprehension abilities precede
productive skills in language learning.
-
The teaching of speaking should be
delayed until comprehension skills are established.
-
Skills acquired through listening
transfer to other skills.
-
Teaching should emphasize meaning
rather than form.
-
Teaching should minimize learner stress.
-
The comprehension approach was supported by Krashen's Monitor Model of second language
acquisition. This model consists of five hypotheses:
-
Acquisition-learning hypothesis (Acquisition
is subconscious, whereas learning is consciously developed by
instruction and aided by error correction).
-
Monitor hypothesis (Conscious learning is limited to use as a
monitor that can edit and make corrections in the learner's
output before s/he writes or speakes, but language fluency relies on acquisition).
-
Natural order hypothesis (Learners acquire linguistic
structures in a predictable order in L1 and a similar order is
present in L2 acquisition).
-
Input hypothesis (Learners acquire
language by exposure to comprehensible input: "i +1".
Learning is first focused on meaning and structure
is learned as a consequence of understanding the message).
-
Affective filter hypothesis
(Depending on the learner’s state of mind, the affective filter
limits what is noticed and what is acquired. The presence of an
affective filter could act as a mental block if a poor affective state existed)
5.2 Approaches to
the Teaching of Listening Skills
Two approaches to the teaching of listening skills, the
natural approach and the total physical response (TPR),
are supported by Krashen's Monitor Model of SLA and grouped
within the broader comprehension approach umbrella.
5.2.1 The Natural Approach
The natural approach, developed by Krashen and Terrell
(1983), focuses on comprehensible input and the optimum affective state
of the learner.
-
Principles and Pedagogical Implications (i.e.,
application to classroom practices):
|
Principles |
Pedagogical implications |
-
Comprehension precedes
productions. That is, listening and reading skills
will be acquired before speaking and writing skills.
|
-
Teachers
speak in the target language only.
-
Content
is selected according to its relevance to student
interests.
-
Teachers
consistently provide comprehensible input.
|
-
Language production
emerges from nonverbal
responses, single words, combinations of two or
three words, to phrases, sentences, and ultimately to
complex discourse.
|
-
The "silent period" is allowed; students are
never forced to speak before they are comfortable
doing so.
-
Error correction is given only when errors
interfere with communication.
|
-
The syllabus and course
content is organized around topics with
communicative goals rather than linguistic
structures.
|
-
The teaching focus is on communicating ideas with little
or no attention to grammatical accuracy in the early
comprehension and production stages.
|
-
The learning environment must
be conducive to language learning.
|
-
Activities should ensure that students can
practice the language in a supportive, nonthreatening setting
that reduces anxiety, promotes motivation,
and builds self-esteem.
|
* Discussion Questions:
-
Is it really good for L2 learners to delay their oral
production?
-
Does the natural approach attend to learners' output? Can
comprehensible input alone lead to learners' comprehensible
output?
-
The Use of Computers in Teaching Listening Skills with the
Natural Approach:
* Discussion Questions:
-
According to your language learning experience with computers,
do you think those CALL programs always provide comprehensible
input, particularly in listening?
-
Do you think the feedback from the computer is sufficient for
language learners to develop their listening skills ?
5.2.2 Total Physical Response (TPR)
Total physical response, developed by Asher (1977), is
frequently used as a technique within a variety of teaching
approaches and methods rather than strictly as an approach unto
itself. It focuses on psychomotor associations and
lowering of the affective filter.
-
Principles and Pedagogical Implications:
|
Principles |
Pedagogical implications |
-
Listening comprehension skills
are developed before oral production skills
(based on the natural order of L1 acquisition).
|
-
Teachers
speak in the target language to students and focus
on students' listening comprehension in the early
stage.
|
-
Psychomotor association:
Learning is enhanced through the association of
language with motor activity. Motor activity is
a function of the right-brain, and the right-brain
activities should precede the language processing
functions of the left-brain.
|
-
Teachers give command forms
(i.e. "Open the door") to which students respond by
physically doing the action.
|
-
TPR lowers students'
affective filter and stress level.
|
-
Teachers ask students to
listen only but not to give an oral response.
|
-
The Use of Computers in Teaching Listening Skills with the
TPR:
Examples:
-
TPR Games (program description from
TPR World Website)
-
Live Action English Interactive
(program description and demo)
-
Review of Live Action Spanish Interactive
(from
Language Learning and Technology,
Vol. 8, No. 3, September 2004, pp. 40-43)
* Discussion Questions:
-
TPR is usually used in the face-to-face classroom. Is there
anything missing when TPR is used on a computer?
-
Please read the program descriptions of "Live Action English
Interactive" and "Live Action Spanish Interactive" and a review
of the Spanish one. Both programs use the principles of TPR to
design for beginning and intermediate adult learners. However,
TPR is usually used to teach languages to younger learners. Do
you think "TPR-on-a-computer" is good for adults to learn
languages? Why or why not?
5.3
Listening Processes
Two types of processes, bottom-up
and top-down, have been identified as central to listening
comprehension.
-
Principles of Bottom-up and
Top-down Processing:
|
Bottom-up Processing |
Top-down Processing |
-
It focuses on individual
linguistic components of discourse.
-
Comprehension is viewed as a
process of decoding messages proceeding from
phonemes to words, to phrases and clauses and other
grammatical elements, to sentences.
|
-
It focuses on
macro-features of discourse such as the
speaker's purpose and the discourse topic.
- Comprehension is viewed as
a process of activating the listener's background
information and schemata* (i.e. prior
knowledge about the context and the topic) for a
global understanding of the message.
|
* Note: "Schemata" is defined as
"plans about the overall structure of events and the relationships
between them" that are stored in the listener's long-term memory
(Richards, 1990). These schemata relate to our real-world
experiences and how we expect people to behave and events to occur.
-
Bottom-up Activities and Top-down Activities in Teaching
Listening Skills:
|
Bottom-up Activities |
Top-down Activities |
-
Identify sounds or lexical
items according to their linguistic function.
-
Use phonological cues to
distinguish between positive and negative sentences
or statements and questions.
-
These activities are designed
to help learners develop their phonological,
lexical, and grammatical knowledge.
-
These activities are often
used for learning phonics and pronunciation
practice.
Examples:
-
American English Pronunciation
Practice
-
Emily's
Pronunciation Class
|
-
Identify the speaker's
communicative purpose or the main idea of discourse.
-
Use schemata to infer the
contextual information from the heard speech or
conversation.
-
These activities are designed
to help learners develop their pragmatic and
discourse knowledge.
-
These activities are often
used for improving communicative skills focusing on
meaning rather than form.
Examples:
-
Randall's ESL Cyber Listening Lab
-
John's ESL
Community - Listening Activities |
* Discussion Question:
-
Based on your English (or other foreign language) learning
experience, what type of listening processes do you use more
often, bottom-up or top-down? In your opinion, what type of
knowledge can CALL programs better help learners to develop,
linguistic or background knowledge? Why? Please give
examples.
5.4 Listening Purposes
-
Interactional Purposes and Transactional Purposes:
According to Brown and Yule (1983), language
communicative functions can be divided into two types:
interactional and transactional functions. Both
language functions are needed for effective classroom
participation. Students use interactional language
to socially interact with each other and their teacher
and engage in transactional uses to develop new skills
and construct new knowledge.
|
Interactional Purposes |
Transactional Purposes |
-
The focus is on
harmonious communication in social contexts.
-
Interactional uses of
language typically include greetings and small
talk that center on noncontroversial topics
that elicit agreement among the
participants.
-
Interactional uses of
language do not require careful attention
to details and facts.
|
-
The focus is on
conveying information and language use is
message oriented.
-
Transactional uses of
language include listening to lectures, taking
notes, and practicing dictations and cloze
exercises that require understanding of
details.
-
Transactional language is
explicit, clear, and coherent
in order for the listener to comprehend the
meaning of the message.
|
-
The Use of Computers in Teaching Listening Skills for Two
Types of Purposes:
|
Teaching for Interactional
Purposes |
Teaching for Transactional
Purposes |
|
Example:
-
Learning Oral English Online
This website offers
interactional speaking practice through dialogs
centered on topics such as making friends, going to
a party, and dating. Students can practice different
aspects of social conversation. This site also
practices another type of interactional listening
that focuses on simple service-oriented tasks such
as ordering lunch and shopping in America.
|
Examples:
-
Randall's ESL Cyber Listening
Lab -
Listening Quizzes for Academic Purposes
-
BBC Learning English: Watch
and Listen - Welcome to London
-
Adult
Learning Activities
-
California Distance Learning
Project
These
websites provide transactional language practice and
are designed to focus on getting information and
promote English development for academic purposes.
|
* Discussion Questions:
-
In everyday language use, we often carry out both
interactional and transactional functions of language at the
same time. Can you always distinguish which language
function you are using? If it is difficult to distinguish
them, then why do we have to learn these two functions
separately?
-
In your opinion, which language function do you think CALL
programs can better help students to learn? Why? Please give
examples.
* Please do
Exercise 5
Using Technology to Teach Listening Skills
 |